| 1 | Pharmaceutical Compliance | Ability to manufacture and control activated carbon intended for pharmaceutical use. | Applicable GMP documentation, quality manual, manufacturing authorization, and product specification aligned with USP–NF, Ph. Eur., or ChP requirements. | 20% | 0–5 points |
| 2 | Batch-to-Batch Consistency | Consistency of adsorption performance, particle size, moisture, ash, and other critical quality attributes. | At least three recent batch Certificates of Analysis and documented statistical trend review. | 15% | 0–5 points |
| 3 | Raw Material Traceability | Traceability of carbonaceous raw materials, processing aids, packaging materials, and production lots. | Supplier qualification records, lot coding, incoming inspection records, and retained-sample procedures. | 10% | 0–5 points |
| 4 | Impurity and Contaminant Control | Control of heavy metals, ash-forming minerals, microbiological contamination, and process-related impurities. | Validated or qualified test methods, recent laboratory results, risk assessments, and impurity specifications. | 15% | 0–5 points |
| 5 | Laboratory Capability | Capability to test physical, chemical, microbiological, and adsorption-related properties. | Calibrated instruments, method validation or verification records, analyst training, and laboratory quality controls. | 10% | 0–5 points |
| 6 | Manufacturing Process Control | Control of carbonization, activation, washing, drying, milling, sieving, and packaging operations. | Process flow diagram, critical process parameter controls, equipment maintenance records, and deviation procedures. | 10% | 0–5 points |
| 7 | Documentation and Change Control | Quality of specifications, batch records, change notifications, deviation investigations, and corrective actions. | Document-control procedure, change-control log, CAPA records, complaint handling, and recall procedure. | 8% | 0–5 points |
| 8 | Supply Capacity and Lead Time | Ability to meet forecasted pharmaceutical demand without compromising quality or delivery reliability. | Validated production capacity, historical on-time delivery data, inventory policy, and business-continuity plan. | 5% | 0–5 points |
| 9 | Packaging and Logistics | Protection against moisture, contamination, mix-ups, and damage during storage and transportation. | Packaging specifications, warehouse controls, transport qualification where applicable, and shipping records. | 4% | 0–5 points |
| 10 | Technical Support and Responsiveness | Speed and quality of technical communication, sample support, complaint response, and regulatory assistance. | Response-time records, technical data packages, sample approval process, and documented customer complaint handling. | 3% | 0–5 points |