| Single seal | General-purpose pumps handling clean or mildly contaminated liquids where a small amount of leakage to the surroundings is acceptable. | Simple arrangement, fewer components, and typically lower initial cost than a dual-seal system. | Does not provide a secondary containment barrier if the primary seal fails. Seal-face lubrication and cooling must be maintained. | Consider for compatible, low-hazard fluids when leakage can be safely managed and the operating conditions are within the seal's rated limits. |
| Dual seal, pressurized | Hazardous, toxic, volatile, or environmentally sensitive fluids; applications requiring a barrier fluid between the inboard and outboard seals. | Barrier fluid is maintained at a pressure above the process pressure, helping prevent process fluid from escaping past the inboard seal. | Requires a suitable barrier-fluid system, monitoring, and maintenance. Barrier-fluid leakage into the process may be unacceptable for some products. | Use when containment is a priority and the process can tolerate the selected barrier fluid. Specify the support system and pressure control with the seal. |
| Dual seal, unpressurized (buffered) | Applications where leakage collection or vapor management is needed, but the process or product should not be exposed to a pressurized barrier fluid. | Provides a secondary seal and a means of managing leakage from the inboard seal. | The buffer fluid is generally at lower pressure than the process, so it does not act as a pressure barrier against process-fluid leakage. | Choose only when the leakage path, buffer-fluid compatibility, and collection or venting arrangements are understood and acceptable. |
| Cartridge seal | Equipment where installation repeatability and reduced field assembly work are important, including many process-pump services. | Preassembled unit helps protect seal faces during handling and reduces the need to set working length during installation. | Must match the equipment's shaft, seal chamber, and connection dimensions. A cartridge design does not by itself determine pressure or temperature capability. | Check the equipment interface dimensions, setting arrangement, flush connections, and operating envelope before ordering or retrofitting. |
| Component seal | Equipment with an established seal chamber and installation process, especially where a compact or serviceable arrangement is preferred. | Can be compact and may allow individual seal parts to be replaced. | Correct installation dimensions and working length are critical; assembly errors can damage faces or cause early leakage. | Select when qualified maintenance personnel can accurately verify the dimensions and follow the specified installation procedure. |
| Pusher seal | Common liquid-pump services where the secondary seal moves axially to accommodate wear and small amounts of shaft movement. | Widely used design with a compact arrangement and a secondary seal that follows face wear. | The dynamic secondary seal can be affected by deposits, corrosion, swelling, or sticking, depending on the fluid and materials. | Assess fluid chemistry, solids, temperature, and secondary-seal material compatibility before choosing this design. |
| Metal bellows seal | Services where an elastomer secondary seal may be unsuitable, or where the design benefits from avoiding a sliding secondary seal along the shaft. | Metal bellows provide axial flexibility without a conventional dynamic elastomer secondary seal at the shaft. | Bellows material must be compatible with the process and temperature. The design has specific limits for pressure, speed, and axial movement. | Consider for demanding temperature or chemical services after checking bellows alloy compatibility and the seal's documented operating limits. |
| Balanced seal | Services with higher seal-chamber pressure or conditions that place substantial hydraulic closing force on the seal faces. | Reduces the hydraulic closing load on the faces compared with a comparable unbalanced design, which can help manage heat and face loading. | Balance ratio and allowable pressure depend on the specific design; balance alone does not establish the seal's pressure rating. | Evaluate seal-chamber pressure, speed, fluid lubricity, and face materials together. Confirm the exact design rating. |
| Unbalanced seal | Lower-pressure services where the seal design and operating conditions keep face loading within acceptable limits. | Can be a straightforward, economical choice for suitable applications. | Higher hydraulic face loading can increase friction and heat as pressure rises, potentially limiting suitability at higher pressures. | Use only within the design's specified pressure and speed limits, with adequate lubrication and heat removal at the seal faces. |
| Gas-lubricated dry-running seal | Specialized compressors and rotating equipment designed for a non-contacting gas seal, rather than a conventional liquid-lubricated pump seal. | Seal faces operate with a thin gas film and are designed to minimize face contact during normal operation. | Requires purpose-designed equipment, clean and appropriately conditioned gas, and controls for start-up, shutdown, and upset conditions. | Consider only when the machine and support systems are engineered for this seal technology; it is not a direct substitute for a standard pump seal. |