| 1 | Slitting quality and dimensional control | 18% | Cut-edge samples, width tolerances, burr or debris measurements, and repeatability test results. | Consistent slit width and clean edges across the specified material, thickness, and operating conditions. |
| 2 | Application and material compatibility | 15% | Documented trials using the buyer’s diaphragm material, coating, thickness, width, and required slit pattern. | Successful, repeatable trials on the actual production material rather than only on a nominally similar substrate. |
| 3 | Machine configuration and process capability | 12% | Technical specifications for web width, material range, speed, blade system, tension control, and changeover options. | The proposed configuration meets the required operating window and provides documented options for the intended process. |
| 4 | Automation and control system | 10% | Control-system documentation, recipe management, sensor functions, alarms, traceability, and interface specifications. | Controls are appropriate to the process, clearly documented, and compatible with the buyer’s operating and data requirements. |
| 5 | Safety and regulatory documentation | 10% | Risk assessment, guarding details, emergency-stop design, operating instructions, and applicable conformity documents. | Safety features and documentation are clearly specified for the destination market and intended installation. |
| 6 | Service, training, and spare-parts support | 10% | Service coverage, response procedures, training scope, spare-parts lists, and parts lead-time commitments. | Support responsibilities, escalation routes, training, and critical spare-parts arrangements are defined in writing. |
| 7 | Reliability and maintainability | 8% | Maintenance schedule, wear-part guidance, service access, and verifiable operating references for comparable applications. | Routine maintenance tasks, wear parts, and access requirements are identified and manageable for the buyer’s facility. |
| 8 | Installation and commissioning capability | 7% | Site requirements, installation plan, acceptance-test procedure, commissioning scope, and operator handover documents. | Responsibilities, prerequisites, acceptance criteria, and commissioning deliverables are agreed before shipment. |
| 9 | Total cost of ownership | 6% | Comparable quotations covering equipment, tooling, installation, training, utilities, consumables, and service. | Costs and exclusions are transparent, enabling comparison over the planned operating period rather than by purchase price alone. |
| 10 | Delivery, communication, and project transparency | 4% | Project schedule, technical clarification records, document control, and written updates on milestones and changes. | Project scope, schedule assumptions, open technical questions, and change-control steps are communicated clearly. |
| Total Suggested Weight | 100% | Score each criterion using documented evidence and application-specific requirements. |